Tom-Ass

Most likely we're going to see the band consist of Axl, Slash, Duff, Pitman, Dizzy, Fortus, and Frank.

That just looks so watered down... Two keyboardists is ridiculous and Frank is awful....

oh because a full reunion wouldnt be?

I don't think it would be or they would have done it a long time ago.. They mended friendships first so why not?

No they don't need a third guitarist or any more damn keyboards. Transcribe guitar parts to keyboards? Really?? Strip it back down.. Dizzy is already more than enough.. I'd be happy to just have Axl play the piano for a song or two..

Having 3 guitarist would suck and how anyone wouldn't want Izzy to be part of this is beyond me. Who gives a fuck if he just stands there.. That is what he does. The chemistry between him and Slash is unmatched and his background vocals sound right. Of course he sounded drowned out in NuGnR.. He wasn't in the band and there were 10 other people on stage.

They won't. Too much interchange at drummer and rhythm guitar for them to even consider it.

ALX------------AXL----------AXL-------AXL

SLASH--------SLASH-------SLASH---SLASH

DUFF----------DUFF--------DUFF-----DUFF

[Guitarist]------Izzy----------Gilby------Richard

[Drummer]-----Steven-------Matt------Frank

I agree with all that except for Frank... Bring back that Brain guy or bring in Brent Fitz if they have to.. Anyone but Frank.. Steven is my # 1 choice though.

Bach got ripped a new asshole when he said to Axl "just release CD" I had to LOL at that. Skid Row reunion would be as big as Ugly Kid Joe reuniting.

Ugly Kid Joe still play..

I actually think a Skid Row reunion would be relatively successful.. I mean they wouldn't be headlining arenas or anything but I bet they could pull in a couple thousand people a show. That isn't bad these days for an old rock band.

New VR candidate if that ship ever sails again? hmmmmm

II

3 good songs out of 14.. The rest are terrible

2/10

Just watched it. Thanks for the heads up.. Short but cool.. Sure was a reminder of how many great songs and solos Slash has spit out.

Can you honestly say Slash's guitar skills have improved since the Illusion era?

Oh my god yes...

Mr. Steven "PopCorn" Adler... no contest

I will never understand the love for Serial Killer.. It comes off as such a cheesy song to me.. There might be some good guitar behind it all but still an awful song.. "I just wanna kill" Ok retard...

How anyone who have truly heard heard their catalog through 1978 and still dislikes Sabbath totally baffles me..

Ash sounds like a fucking douche

Great interview right there. Steven really seems to be doing well. I am happy for him...

Wow, that was fucking awesome.. I had never seen or heard of that before.

Tough call... Probably Estranged only because it isn't as played out.. Can't vote though

http://ultimateclassicrock.com/guns-n-roses-reunion-steven-adler-2/

The only genuinely "bad" tracks on the UYIs are Get in the Ring and Shotgun Blues. Whereas on CD, every song except for Catcher, Better, TWAT, Shackler's and Rhiad is pretty damn mediocre. 9 songs out of 14 are easily filler and definitely forgettable.

I like both Shotgun and Get In The Ring

Never experience a filler on a GNR record before.

My World, Scraped and Anything Goes disagree with you.

I wouldn't call Anything Goes filler either.. Some people may not like it as much as the rest of the album but it is still a damn good song...

They never quit smack for good.

Slash and Izzy were on the shit too...

some new material, unleash Axl/Izzy/Slash magic!

nothing against covers, so far they did great job with covers/owned all the covers they did. I can totally see them cover this:

oh my god that was awesome... Thanks for that.. Any idea how the rest of the album is?

If it happens I sure hope they consider giving him a chance.. He isn't the only one of the guys who was a junkie and he seems to be doing a lot better lately.

Axl said that he had to go through hell while making UYI albums. There were constant phonecalls where everyone said "Im not doing this song until you do mine". At the end nobody gave a fck anymore.

Axl did My World.

Slash did Coma.

Duff did So Fine.

Izzy did 14 Years.

Axl n duff did get in the ring (another pathetic song).

Axl did My world without anyone knowing. Just an out of the box way to end an album. I don't hate it.

Slash and Axl did Coma.. It was Slash's riff and the guitars are great but Axl shaped the song quite a bit if not more so. Definitely a collaboration.

So Fine sucks

14 years is good. I kind of wish Axl took more of a backseat during the chorus though. Maybe a little lower in the mix.

I always liked Get In the Ring and still do.. Might not be everyone's cup of tea but I wouldn't call it pathetic.

nice, gonna try that one

any listening suggestions of stuff by the older guys?

My favorite old timer is Howlin' Wolf.. It is more about his voice than the guitars though. Izzy used to do some of his covers.. Some were songs that were done by a lot of blues guys but Izzy did Wolf's versions.

Killing floor

Smokestack Lightning

Evil

Highway 49

highway 49 (Izzy)

Spoonful

Spoonful (Izzy)